Suggestion, problem or idea: how to choose what to post
Two questions settle it: does this belong to a product that already exists, and do you already know what the fix looks like.
Every post on Suggst is one of three kinds: a suggestion, a problem or an idea. Picking the right one matters more than it seems, because each kind reaches different people. Suggestions go to a product's team. Problems go to builders looking for something worth making. Ideas go to anyone who might want to build them or back them.
Most of the time the choice takes a few seconds. This guide covers how to make it, what to do when something could be two kinds, and two short quizzes to check yourself.
The short version
- Suggestion: a feature or change for a product that already exists. "Let me split a Swiggy order with friends on UPI."
- Problem: something hard or annoying that no product solves well. "Finding out when the water tanker will reach our building."
- Idea: a product or business you wish existed. "A shared calendar for a housing society, with tanker, maintenance and lift repair dates in one place."
Post a suggestion when the product exists
A suggestion is tied to a product's page, and that is its strength. If the product's team has claimed their page, they can reply on your post and set its status to planned, in progress, shipped or not planned. If they pick it up, the post shows Picked by with the product's name. Even before a team claims its page, the post is public and collects votes from other people who use the product.
Suggestions also get a mark the other kinds do not: people voting can say I use this product. That tells the team the request comes from their own users, not from people passing by.
Write a suggestion when you use the product and can point to the moment it lets you down. "On BookMyShow, show the view from a seat before I book it" is a suggestion. So is "On Paytm, let me add a note to a payment after it goes through." (Both are made-up examples of the format.) If you want help writing one well, this guide to feature requests walks through it.
Post a problem when nobody solves it well
A problem is not tied to any product. It describes something hard, slow, expensive or annoying, and leaves the fix open. That openness is the point. Builders browse problems to find what to make next, and a problem that leaves room for different solutions gives them more to work with.
Good problem posts read like a scene: who you are, what happened, how often, what you do today. On a problem, people can vote, mark I'd pay for this, answer How often does this happen to you?, and pledge an amount, as in "I'd pay ₹X if someone builds this". Nothing is charged. Builders can mark I'm building this, and the people who wanted it hear when the build launches.
Post a problem when you have looked for a product that handles it and come up empty, or when the products that exist all miss the same thing.
Post an idea when you can picture the product
An idea is a product or business you wish existed. You post one when you have more than a frustration: you can describe what the thing would do and who would use it. Ideas get votes, pledges and I'm building this marks, just like problems.
If you are worried someone will take it, know that every post has a public record. Suggst makes a timestamp proof with OpenTimestamps when you post, so anyone can later check who posted first. That does not stop anyone from building it, and it is not meant to. It means there is a public record that you spotted it first.
When it could be two
Some posts sit on a line. A few cases come up again and again:
- The problem is inside one app. If the fix belongs in a specific product you use, post a suggestion to that product. Its team is the one who can fix it.
- The problem is wider than any one app. If several products could solve it, or none comes close, post a problem.
- You have a problem and a solution. If you are not sure the solution is right, post the problem and describe your solution in the body. If you are sure, post the idea and describe the problem it solves.
When in doubt between a problem and an idea, choose the problem. It is easier to agree with "I keep missing the water tanker" than with one particular app design, so people who share the pain can vote even if they would fix it differently.
The same frustration as an idea and as a problem
Starts with the solution
An app where housing societies can track water tankers with live GPS and push alerts.
Check yourself
Two quick scenarios. Pick the kind of post you would make.
Quick question
You order on Zomato every week and wish you could see how a restaurant packs its food before you order. What should you post?
Quick question
You teach tuition from home. Parents often pay late, and you keep track in a notebook. You do not know of an app that handles this well, and you have no particular fix in mind. What should you post?
Whichever you pick, you can write it in Hindi or any language you are comfortable in. Suggst AI lays it out in English and keeps your original. You can also start from a screenshot if the trouble is on a screen.
Post what is on your mind as a suggestion, a problem or an idea.
Write a requestWritten by the Suggst team. Example requests about real apps are made up to show how to write them, not reports about those apps.